记录观察
Documenting Observations
在我的家庭式托育项目中,我在签到表旁放了一本沟通记录本,为每个家庭留出各自的记录区。我用它简要记下所照护的孩子的言语和行动,方便之后回看。通常,在家长翻看记录本之前,我就会记得把当天观察到的孩子的情况告诉他们。
In my family child care program, I keep a communication notebook with sections for each family by the sign-in sheet. I use it to jot down quick notes about things I see my children do and say so I can refer back to them later. I usually remember to tell parents what I observed about their child during the day even before they check the notebook.
有一天,来接 Tomás 的是他的祖母,而不是父亲。她正准备带 Tomás 出门时,注意到了记录本。她翻到 Tomás 的记录区,读到“Tomás——木制摇摆船的故事——与 Eli 分享”,便问这是什么意思。我告诉她,我观察到12个月大的 Tomás 和我照护的一位年龄较大的幼儿 Eli,成功地协商好了如何共用木制摇摆船。他们商量好了谁先上船、各自坐哪个座位。这一次没有像之前尝试时那样哭泣或推搡,他们平静地一起摇了好几分钟。
One day, Tomás's grandmother came to pick him up instead of his father. She was just about to walk out the door with Tomás when she noticed the notebook. She looked in Tomás's section, read "Tomás—wooden rocking boat story—shared with Eli," and asked what that meant. I told her that I had watched Tomás, who is 12 months old, and Eli, one of my older toddlers, successfully negotiate how to share the wooden rocking boat. They figured out who got in the boat first and who sat in which seat. There was no crying or pushing as there had been in past attempts, and they peacefully rocked for several minutes.
Tomás 的祖母听了,显得非常高兴。Tomás 是独生子,和其他孩子相处、分享空间与玩具的经历还不多。看到这个故事对她的意义,我意识到了两件事:随手记下观察是多么重要,与所有家庭成员分享这些观察又是多么重要!
Tomás's grandmother seemed so pleased to hear this. Tomás is an only child. He hasn't had much experience being around other children and sharing space and toys. When I saw what this story meant to her, I realized two things: how important it is to jot down my observations and how important it is to share them with all family members!
可以用多种方法记录孩子的言语和行动;对于家访人员,还可以记录家长、其他家庭成员与孩子共同互动时的言语和行动。选择哪种方法,取决于教育工作人员想了解什么、孩子当时正在说什么和做什么,以及工作人员个人的记录风格。此外,各种方法对时间和精力的要求也不同。本节将简要介绍教育工作人员可能使用的一些较常见的记录方法。
Various methods may be used to capture what children do and say—and for home visitors, what parents and family members and their child do and say together. The decision about what method to use depends on what education staff want to learn, what children are saying and doing at the time, and personal style. Additionally, each method makes different demands on time and energy. This section briefly reviews some of the more common documentation methods education staff are likely to use.
音频与影像记录
Audio and Visual Recordings
相机和录音录像设备,包括智能手机和平板电脑,能够快速、高效地记录孩子的言语和行动。对于选择使用这些设备的早期开端计划(EHS)和流动及季节性务工家庭开端计划(MSHS),应考虑以下事项:
Cameras and media recorders, including smartphones and tablets, offer quick, efficient ways to document what children say and do. For EHS and MSHS programs that choose to use these devices, consider the following:
以下方面的费用:
Costs for:
购买相机、录音录像设备,以及用于下载、存储、播放和打印文件的设备与软件。
Buying the cameras and recorders, equipment, and software to download, store, play, and print files
如果使用非数码相机,还需考虑胶卷冲洗费用。
Film development if not using a digital camera
日常维护费用,例如电池和维修。
Upkeep (e.g., batteries, repair)
取得家庭的理解与支持,以及由家庭签署的书面许可,同意为观察目的给孩子拍照、录音或录像。
Buy-in and signed, written permission from families to photograph or record their child for observation purposes
鼓励工作人员将录音和视频控制为较短的片段。片段越长,文件越大;大文件会占用较多存储空间。较长的录音和视频,在之后回看和分析时也需要更多时间。保存记录时,应附上便于识别该记录的相关信息,例如日期和时间、情境、参与的儿童和成人姓名,以及录制时所处的一日生活环节或游戏活动。当工作人员反思观察让自己了解了每个孩子的哪些情况,并据此提供个别化照护与课程时,这些信息十分重要。照片、视频片段和录音片段,也是向家庭具体展示孩子知道什么、能够做什么的很好工具。
Encourage staff to keep audio and video clips short. The longer the clip, the larger the file; large files take up a lot of storage space. Long audio and video clips also take more time to review and analyze later. When saving the recordings, include relevant information to identify the recording (e.g., date and time, setting, names of children and adults, routine or play experience during which the recording was made). This information will be important when staff reflect on what their observations tell them about each child and use that information to individualize care and the curriculum. Photographs, video clips, and audio clips are also excellent, concrete tools for conveying to families what children know and can do.
核对表及其他纸质记录工具
Checklists and Other Print Recording Tools
核对表、频次计数表和参与情况记录表等工具,可用于快速记录特定行为或技能出现的情况。这些工具的一个显著特点是:需要观察的行为或技能已经预先明确。工作人员通过打勾、画计数符号,或注明观察到该技能或行为的日期,来记录所观察到的行为或技能。¹
Tools such as checklists, frequency counts, and participation charts are used to quickly record information about the occurrence of specific behaviors or skills. A defining feature of these tools is that the behaviors or skills are already identified. Staff record the observed behavior or skill by using check or tally marks or noting the date on which the skill or behavior was seen.¹
原文脚注 / Source notes
1. Oralie McAfee、Deborah J. Leong 与 Elena Bodrova:《评估基础:幼儿教育工作者入门指南》(华盛顿特区:美国幼儿教育协会,2004年),第40—41页。
1. Oralie McAfee, Deborah J. Leong, and Elena Bodrova, Basics of Assessment: A Primer for Early Childhood Educators (Washington, DC: National Association for the Education of Young Children, 2004), 40–41.
书面观察:速记、轶事记录与连续记录
Written Observations: Jottings, Anecdotal Notes, and Running Records
工作人员用速记来简要提醒自己观察到的事情。速记通常用简短的词组或句子描述单次事件或互动,例如:“Matthias 把三块外包泡沫的大积木叠起来,看着爸爸,说‘Bwocks!’”
Staff use jottings as quick reminders of things they have observed. These jottings tend to have short phrases or sentences that describe a single event or interaction; for example, "Matthias stacks three large foam-covered blocks, looks at Dad, says 'Bwocks!' "
工作人员用轶事记录记下一次具体事件,通常聚焦于特定的技能、行为或互动。记录中包含多少细节,由工作人员决定。轶事记录通常比速记更详尽。不过,轶事记录也可以从速记开始,之后再补充更多细节。
Staff use anecdotal notes to document a particular occurrence and typically focus on specific skills, behaviors, or interactions. Staff determine how much detail to include in an anecdotal note. These notes tend to be more extensive than jottings. However, anecdotal notes may start out as jottings, with additional details added later.
工作人员用连续记录,在一个特定时段内收集详细的叙述性信息。在观察期间,随着事件和行为的发生,他们按发生顺序记录自己看到和听到的一切。这类记录内容详尽,能够呈现儿童丰富而全面的面貌。不过,它需要专门留出时间,退后一步观察并书写;工作人员在照护儿童、开展家访或组织小组社交活动时,可能难以投入这么多时间。项目督导人员可以使用连续记录,作为持续支持工作人员的一部分,或用于了解某个孩子的具体问题。班级教师使用这种方法时,应考虑如何维持1:4的工作人员与儿童比例(九人小组则为1:3),并确保教师专注记录期间,整个小组仍能得到有效照护与看护。项目可以考虑为此安排额外工作人员。
Staff use running records to collect detailed narrative information during a specific time frame. They write everything they see and hear, as events and behaviors occur and in the order in which they occur, during the observation period. These narratives are extensive and provide a rich, comprehensive view of children. However, they require more dedicated time for stepping back, observing, and writing than staff may have while caring for children, or during a home visit or group socialization. Running records may be useful for a program supervisor to collect as part of ongoing staff support or if there is a specific issue with a child. When a teacher in a classroom uses this method, consider ways to maintain the 1:4 staff-child ratio (or 1:3 ratio for a group size of nine) and ensure the entire group is effectively covered and supervised while the teacher is engaged. Programs may want to have additional staff available for this purpose.
无论采用哪种书面观察记录方式,记录的信息都需要准确、客观,并以不带偏见的方式呈现所描述的一个或多个孩子。
Regardless of which type of written observation is used, the recorded information needs to be accurate, objective, and provide an unbiased view of the child or children being described.
撰写客观、准确的观察记录
Writing Objective and Accurate Observation Notes
关于婴幼儿的书面观察记录,应当基于事实、保持客观,才能有用且有意义。¹ 这意味着教育工作人员应只记录自己看到和听到的内容,也就是事实,并避免使用以下类型的词语:
Written observations about infants and toddlers should be factual and objective to be useful and meaningful¹. This means education staff should write only what they see and hear (e.g., the facts) and avoid using words that:
表达对孩子的感受、意图和动机的判断。
Communicate judgment about a child's feelings, intentions, and motivations
含义模糊,可能有不同解释。
Are ambiguous and open to interpretation
表达个人看法。
Describe an opinion
工作人员可以通过自问来检视自己的客观性:“我对这个孩子的行为和互动的描述,与另一个观察这个孩子的人可能作出的描述,是否相同或相近?”² 请看下面两份关于8个月大的 Umar 的观察记录:
One way in which staff may think about their own objectivity is to ask themselves, "Am I describing this child's behaviors and interactions in the same or a similar way that someone else observing this child would describe them?"² Consider the following observation notes about 8-month-old Umar:
编者阅读提示:记录1含主观判断;记录2描述可观察的事实。 / Editor’s reading guide: Note 1 includes judgments; Note 2 describes observable facts.
记录1:11月29日,上午8点,入园
Note 1: 11/29, 8 a.m., arrival
妈妈带 Umar 进房间时,他很难适应。他不喜欢被放到地板上。妈妈试着给他读书时,他不理睬她。他爬到 Lettie 身边,从她手里拿走球;妈妈亲吻他、说再见并离开房间时,他变得难过。
Umar has a hard time when his mom brings him into the room. He doesn't like being put down on the floor. Ignores her when she tries to read a book to him. Crawls over to Lettie, takes ball from her hands; gets upset when mom kisses him, says goodbye, and leaves the room.
记录2:11月29日,上午8点,入园
Note 2: 11/29, 8 a.m., arrival
妈妈抱着 Umar 走进房间,把他放在图书筐旁的地板上。Umar 发出呜咽声(没有眼泪)。妈妈在他身旁坐下,从筐里拿出一本书,把封面展示给 Umar,开始读。Umar 把头转向另一边,看见 Lettie(另一名幼儿)拿着一个内有铃铛的球摇晃,向她伸出双臂,爬过去坐在她旁边,从她手中拿过球,摇晃起来。妈妈走到 Umar 身边,亲吻他,说再见,然后走出去。Umar 开始哭(有眼泪)。
Umar's mom carries him into the room, sets him down on floor next to book bin. Umar makes whimpering sounds (no tears). Mom sits down next to him, picks a book from the bin, shows cover to Umar, begins to read. Umar turns his head away, sees Lettie (child) holding and shaking a ball with a bell inside, holds his arms out to her, crawls over and sits next to her, takes ball from her hands, shakes it. Mom goes to Umar, kisses him, says goodbye, walks out. Umar starts to cry (tears).
两份观察记录都描述了 Umar 与妈妈分开的过程,但第一份包含了教师对 Umar 行为的假设和解释。读到这份记录的人,可能对发生的事情产生不同理解,因为“很难适应”“不喜欢”“不理睬”“变得难过”等词语都可能有不同解释。第二份记录是在描述 Umar 的行为,而不是解释行为。它更清楚地呈现了 Umar 在入园环节中实际做了什么、说了什么。
Both observation notes describe how Umar separates from his mother, but the first note contains the teacher's assumptions about and interpretations of Umar's behavior. Someone reading this note may have different ideas about what happened because words such as "hard time," "doesn't like," "ignores," and "gets upset" are open to interpretation. The second note describes rather than interprets Umar's behaviors. It provides a much clearer picture about what Umar actually does and says during the arrival routine.
客观、基于事实的书面观察记录包括以下内容:
Objective, factual written observations include the following:
对动作的描述。
Descriptions of actions
对儿童发出的声音的描述。
Descriptions of children's vocalizations
直接引用儿童的原话。
Direct quotes of children's language
对面部表情和手势的描述。
Descriptions of facial expressions and gestures
对作品的描述,例如搭叠的积木、涂鸦和手指画。
Descriptions of creations (e.g., stacked blocks, scribble drawings, finger-painted pictures)
以下词语经常出现在书面观察记录中。³ 但这些词语及其他类似表达可能有多种解释,并带有判断,应当避免使用。
The following words are often found in written observation notes.³ However, these and other similar words can be interpreted in many ways and express judgment. They should be avoided.
编者标注:下列为原文中的反例,展示应避免的表达。 / Editor’s label: The following source examples illustrate wording to avoid.
智力:聪明、迟钝。
Intelligence: smart, slow
Lyle 正确地完成了两块形状拼图。他真是个聪明的宝宝!
Lyle completes the two-piece shape puzzle correctly. He is such a smart baby!
感受:生气、恼怒、悲伤、难过、开心。
Feelings: angry, mad, sad, upset, happy
Jorge 生气了,把玩水桌里的水泼到了地板上。
Jorge gets angry and splashes water from the water table on the floor.
意图与偏好:想要、喜欢、喜爱、“因为”。
Intentions and preferences: wants, likes, loves, "because"
Andre 捡起 Sonia 掉落的娃娃时,Sonia 打了他,因为她想把自己的娃娃拿回来。
Sonia hits Andre when he picks up the doll she dropped because she wants her doll back.
标签:无聊、分心、配合、有攻击性、过度活跃、乐于助人、退缩、害羞、外向、爱哭闹、坏、好、傻气、可爱、漂亮。
Labels: bored, distracted, cooperative, aggressive, hyperactive, helpful, withdrawn, shy, outgoing, fussy, bad, good, silly, cute, beautiful
我试着喂 Inette 时,她分心了。她一直把头转向另一边。
Inette was distracted when I tried to feed her. She kept turning her head away.
评价:做得好、做得不好。
Evaluations: good job, bad job
Oliver 收拾玩具做得很好。
Oliver does a good job putting the toys away.
时间与数量:总是、从不、很多、很长时间、很短时间。
Time and amounts: always, never, a lot, long time, short time
祖父离开房间后,Hannah 过了很长时间才平静下来、停止哭泣。
It took a long time for Hannah to settle down and stop crying after her grandfather left the room.
理解儿童行为和互动的意义很重要。对孩子的印象、感受和见解,对于提供个别化支持极有价值。不过,工作人员首先需要准确、基于事实的信息,之后才能对儿童的技能、行为、兴趣和需要作出判断。
Interpreting the meaning of children's behaviors and interactions is important. Impressions, feelings, and insights about children are extremely valuable to the individualizing process. However, staff first need accurate, factual information to draw conclusions later on about children's skills, behavior, interests, and needs.
原文脚注 / Source notes
1. 美国国家婴幼儿照护倡议:《婴幼儿发展、筛查与评估》(华盛顿特区:美国卫生与公众服务部,2010年),第22页。
1. National Infant & Toddler Child Care Initiative, Infant/Toddler Development, Screening, and Assessment (Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2010), 22.
2. Laura J. Colker:《幼儿观察培训者指南:学习观察,通过观察学习》(华盛顿特区:Teaching Strategies,1995年),第7页。
2. Laura J. Colker, A Trainer’s Guide to Observing Young Children: Learning to Look, Looking to Learn (Washington, DC: Teaching Strategies, 1995), 7.
3. 同上,第7页;Derry G. Koralek、Amy Laura Dombro 与 Diane Trister Dodge:《婴幼儿照护》,第2版(华盛顿特区:Teaching Strategies,2005年),第372页。
3. Ibid, 7; Derry G. Koralek, Amy Laura Dombro, and Diane Trister Dodge, Caring for Infants & Toddlers, 2nd ed. (Washington, DC: Teaching Strategies, 2005), 372.
关于准确性的说明
A Note About Accuracy
观察记录不仅需要客观、基于事实,还需要准确。准确的观察记录应按事实发生的顺序书写。¹ 请看下面这个关于33个月大的 Gabriel 的故事,事情发生在一次社交活动中。一位家访人员观察了整个互动过程:
Observation notes need to be accurate as well as objective and factual. Accurate observation notes include facts that are written in the order in which they occur.¹ Consider the following story about 33-month-old Gabriel, which takes place during a socialization experience. A home visitor observes the entire exchange:
编者标注:以下为原文描述的实际经过。 / Editor’s label: The actual sequence as described in the source.
Gabriel 和妈妈在彼此身旁,各自用大块塑料积木搭一座塔。Gabriel 把自己的塔搭得和自己一样高。他的手臂碰到了塔。塔倒了,碰倒了妈妈搭的积木塔。Gabriel 笑起来,一边拍手一边上下跳。妈妈也笑了,拍拍手,然后拥抱了 Gabriel。
Gabriel and his mom are next to each other. Each one is building a tower using large plastic blocks. Gabriel builds his tower as tall as he is. He bumps into the tower with his arm. The tower falls over and knocks down the block tower that his mother built. Gabriel laughs and jumps up and down while clapping his hands. His mom laughs, claps her hands, and hugs Gabriel.
下面是家访人员写下的观察记录:
Here is the home visitor's observation note:
编者标注:以下为不准确记录的反例,顺序错误且有信息遗漏。 / Editor’s label: An inaccurate note with events out of order and information omitted.
Gabriel 用大块塑料积木搭了一座和自己一样高的塔。他开始笑、上下跳、拍手,然后碰到了自己的塔,把它和妈妈的塔都碰倒了。
Gabriel builds a tower as tall as he is using large plastic blocks. He starts to laugh, jump up and down, clap his hands, and bumps into his tower, knocking it down and his mom's tower down, too.
这份观察记录并不准确。它把事实的顺序写乱了,例如先写笑、上下跳、拍手,再写碰到积木塔。它还遗漏了一些信息,例如 Gabriel 和妈妈在彼此身旁,各自搭了一座塔,以及妈妈笑、拍手并拥抱 Gabriel。准确性很重要。长此以往,不准确的观察记录可能导致对孩子知道什么、能够做什么、如何与他人互动等方面作出不准确的解释,或产生误解。
This observation note is not accurate. It contains facts that are out of order (e.g., laughs, jumps up and down, claps his hands, and bumps into his tower). It is also missing information (e.g., Gabriel and his mother are next to each other; each one is building a tower; Gabriel's mom laughs, claps her hands, and hugs Gabriel). Accuracy matters. Over time, inaccurate observation notes may lead to inaccurate interpretations or misunderstandings of what a child knows and can do, how the child interacts with others, and so on.
以下是撰写观察记录的其他建议:
Here are additional tips for writing observation notes:
记下儿童和观察者的姓名。
Note the child's name and the observer's name
记下观察的日期和时间、情境(例如室内或室外、一日生活环节、游戏活动),以及参与其中的其他儿童或成人。
Note the date and time of the observation, setting (e.g., indoor or outdoor, routine, play experience), and other children or adults involved
使用缩写、简短词组、符号、简图,以及自己设计的其他速记方式,快速记下信息。
Use abbreviations, short phrases, symbols, drawn pictures, and other shorthand inventions to quickly capture information
按照实际发音拼写,记录儿童发出的声音(例如 buh-buh-buh-mmmm)和尝试说出的词语(例如把 please 说成“peez”)。
Use phonetic spellings to capture children's vocalizations (e.g., buh-buh-buh-mmmm) and word attempts (e.g., "peez" for "please")
条件允许时,与一位伙伴共同观察,例如搭班教师、专业同事、教育协调员或家庭成员;随后对照记录,看看是否记录了相同的信息,以及是否使用了相近的语言。
When possible, observe with a partner (e.g., co-teacher, professional colleague, education coordinator, family member) and compare notes to see if the same information was recorded and if it was recorded using similar language
写出准确、客观、基于事实的观察记录,需要时间和练习。不过,工作人员可以在一天中有计划地安排记录的机会,有意识地、经过思考地书写。
Writing accurate, objective, factual observation notes takes time and practice. However, staff can plan for opportunities during the day to write notes intentionally and thoughtfully.
原文脚注 / Source notes
1. Koralek、Dombro 与 Dodge:《婴幼儿照护》,第373页。
1. Koralek, Dombro, and Dodge, Caring for Infants & Toddlers, 373.
